Thursday, February 28, 2013

Alex Smith Is Fools Gold

The San Francisco 49ers have agreed to trade quarterback Alex Smith to the Kansas City Chiefs for a 2nd round pick.  This comes as no surprise since the 49ers found their quartrerback of the future in Colin Kaepernick and the 2013 NFL draft is light on signal callers.  Although Alex Smith has an impressive record in his last 25 starts (19-5-1) will he be a good fit for the Chiefs going forward?

Absolutely not.  The last two seasons Alex Smith played on a team that went to the NFC championship game and the Super Bowl.  The 49ers had a top 5 defense and an established running game.  The Chiefs had the worst record in the NFL playing in a mediocre division.  Alex Smith is used to playing in a system that doesn't ask him to do too much and Kansas City needs their quarterback to be dynamic.

In addition, coach Andy Reid is used to dealing with the likes of Bret Favre, Donovan McNabb, and Michael Vick.  Alex Smith doesn't possess that kind of ability.  In the pass happy offense Reid traditionally runs it will be difficult for Smith to duplicate his recent success.  He's never been known for his accuracy down field or making plays with his feet.  If he has to throw 35 to 40 times a game the Chiefs will struggle.

The Alex Smith trade says more about the 2013 NFL draft and free agency than it does about his potential to make the Chiefs relevant again.  There is no Andrew Luck or RGIII to be taken with the #1 pick and no big name free agent looking for a new home.  Alex Smith is certainly better than Geno Smith (no relation) and Matt Barkley so the logic is sound, but I think the results will be less than expected.  The Chiefs have too many problems for Alex Smith to be the answer.  Your thoughts?

Wednesday, February 27, 2013

Violence In The NBA

Sometimes the ESPN ticker can be misleading.  Last night the Indiana Pacers and the Golden St. Warriors got into a so called brawl that spilled into the crowd.  During the melee Pacers center Roy Hibbert and Warriors forward David Lee made contact with fans on the sidelines and almost escalated further.  On the surface this incident sounds like another horrible episode and a PR nightmare for the NBA, but in reality it was a success story.

I started watching the fight with the anticipation I was going to see the Palace Brawl II.  After 10 seconds I was highly irritated.  No one threw a punch, everybody looked scared, and the only person with any real fire was little old Steph Curry.  Truth be told you would probably see more violence at a Celine Dion concert.  These guys would make Screech from Saved by the Bell look tough.  Has the NBA really become that soft?

Absolutely.  The rules are different, the culture is different, the penalties are severe, and this generation is more passive and collaborative.  The players see themselves as co-workers or fraternity brothers as opposed to adversaries or rivals.  There is no such thing as "bad blood" and altercations that used to linger for years get squashed over the weekend.  In addition, players realize fighting not only hurts them financially, but the impending suspension could cost the team in the long run.  No one wants to be the guy that costs their team a championship for fighting.

As much as I would love to see these guys scrap like they did back in the day (imagine Kobe vs. LeBron) I understand the league's non violent policy is for the greater good.  Nobody gets hurt and the player's mind set has shifted.  Charles Oakley and Xavier McDaniel are not walking out of that locker room!

Tuesday, February 26, 2013

Myths About The NFL Combine

The NFL scouting combine is an opportunity for future NFL prospects to showcase their talents and impress team executives.  For some the audition goes well while others fall flat on their face.  A few years back the combine was the end all be all, but in recent years we've seen the impact diminished.  The top prospects usually host individual work outs and marginal players routinely decide the risk isn't worth the reward.  A bad performance could cost them several spots in the draft.  With limited participation is the combine still relevant?

Yes and no.  At this point the combine is really more to confirm the physical attributes of the top players as opposed to finding a diamond in the rough.  There is so much information, analysis, and video footage there's few surprises.  The ones that benefit the most are players from small schools that don't get national exposure, but have the talent to excel at the next level. 

In addition, the combine drills don't always accurately project who's going to be a star.  The top performers in each individual work out category rarely see those results translate on the field.  Just because you can lift 225 pounds 30+ times or run a sub 4.4 40 time doesn't mean you have Hall of Fame potential.  The game is about more than isolated physical gifts.

The NFL scouting combine is useful, but not always a solid indication of how good a player will be.  The game is still played on the field and the drills don't measure intangibles like leadership, durability, and instincts.  It's a good frame of reference, but it doesn't tell the whole story.

Thursday, February 21, 2013

Richard Sherman vs. Darelle Revis

As you all know I'm a big fan of trash talking athletes.  Not the ones that run their mouth then get trounced by their opponents, but the ones that talk the talk and walk the walk.  The Gary Payton's of the world.  The Michael Irvin's of the world.  The Floyd Mayweather Jr's of the world.  For the 2nd time in my adult life one of these human megaphones plays in the 206.  His name is Richard Sherman.

Richard Sherman is the kind of guy that will rip your skin off just to get on your nerves, a certified chatter box.  He's the kind of guy that could provoke Mother Teresa into taking a swing at him.  He talks so much he makes Kanye West seem humble.  You almost want to see him fail so you won't have to hear his mouth.  Like most great trash talkers Richards Sherman is constantly looking for new victims and sources of motivation.  His latest target is Darelle Revis.

Sherman has pulled Revis into his world and the war of words is in full swing.

From Revis:

I've never seen a man run his mouth so much like a girl.  This dude is steady putting my name in his mouth to get notoriety.  Sit down young pup and wait your turn.

From Sherman:

Don't need ya name...Ur name will be irrelevant once u step back on the field bruh.  Get ya picks up!

For the record I think Darelle Revis is slightly better, but I like where Sherman's head is at.  If you're going to proclaim yourself the best cornerback in the game you might as well go after the top dog!  I'm sure this is not the last we will hear about this new found rivalry and the fodder can only help Sherman and the Seahawks.  The position requires supreme confidence and it's obvious Sherman has it in spades.  Too bad we won't get full resolution to his claims for another 10 months.  Who do you think is better?

Tuesday, February 19, 2013

Jerry Buss: The Greatest Owner Ever

I was watching ESPN yesterday when I heard the news Laker owner Jerry Buss passed away at the age of 80.  The news came as a shock to me.  I heard he was in the hospital, but had no idea of the severity of his condition.  After hearing some of the comments made by former players, executives, and reporters the legacy of Jerry Buss is absolutely mind boggling.  During his 34 year tenure as owner the Lakers had 16 World Championship appearances, 19 division titles, and 10 NBA titles.  If I stopped right there he would be considered one of the greatest owners in the history of professional sports.

As I delve further it gets even more ridiculous.  It can be argued that his former players Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Magic Johnson, Shaq, and Kobe Bryant are among the 10 greatest players to ever play basketball.  It can be argued that Phil Jackson and Pat Riley are 2 of the 3 greatest coaches in NBA history.  From 1980 to 1991 the Lakers played for the championship 9 times.  From 2000 to 2010 the Lakers played for the championship 7 times.  In the era of free agency and salary escalation this type of dominance is unfathomable.

In addition, Jerry Buss forged a partnership with Magic Johnson that is unheard of in professional sports today.  Not only did they kick it together at the Playboy mansion after games (who does that), but he also made him the highest played player and gave him part ownership of the team when his playing days were over.  Magic credits his experience with Buss as the main reason he's been so successful as a businessman.

Buss also brought excitement and entertainment to the NBA.  With the Laker girls and the up style tempo of play the Lakers became an event that attracted stars and high profile people from all walks of life.  Jack Nicholson, Denzel Washington, Penny Marshall, and countless other celebrities are routinely seen at Laker games.  That didn't exist before Jerry Buss.  The experience turned Paula Abdul and Karyn White into stars.  Amazing you can go from being a cheerleader
to being a Grammy winning performer. 

It's safe to say this kind of success won't be duplicated in our lifetime and his absence is already being felt.  The Lakers have been nothing short of dysfunctional since he passed the reigns over to his son Jimmy and without his presence and guidance I don't see things getting better anytime soon.  It's sad that such an incredible legacy can't be sustained.  Then again if you heard the numbers and the stats I just rattled off a franchise would be lucky to achieve 1/10 of that.  The Lakers have been fortunate, but they've also been resourceful and calculating.  It's no surprise other teams have tried to follow their blueprint (Boston, Miami, New York), but I doubt they can match the production.  I don't know what your criteria is for determining the greatest owner in sports history is, but whatever it is Jerry Buss should be at the top of the list.  Laker Nation lost a great man, innovator, and owner.  RIP Jerry. 

Friday, February 15, 2013

The Nerlens Noel Case Study

On Tuesday Kentucky freshman Nerlens Noel tore his ACL and will miss the rest of the season.  It is a devastating injury that has caused a ripple effect throughout the college basketball world.  From the mind of an over analytical sports enthusiast this story is compelling on many levels.  Depending on how you look at it the Noel injury has a different meaning.

The cynical perspective:

I guess he'll have to start going to that biology class he's been skipping for the last 3 weeks.  Don't think David Stern will be calling his name this June.  The John Calipari recruiting speech suddenly has to add an injury clause to the verbiage.  All you one and done guys better stop counting your chickens before they hatch.

The paranoid perspective:

You saw what happened to Noel.  Forget North Carolina, I'm going overseas when I graduate from high school.  I gotta get my cheese while there's still time.  I gotta strike while the iron is hot and my stock is on the rise.  I got too much to lose and you never know what can happen.  Nothing in life is guaranteed.

The rival perspective:

Now that Kentucky doesn't have Big Noel in the middle they are vulnerable.  I wasn't going to buy tickets to the SEC tournament before, but now our team has a legitimate shot to win.  We don't wish bad things on anyone and Nerlens seems like a good kid, but Kentucky's loss is our gain.  They get whatever they want most of the time so you can't feel too bad for their misfortune.

The purist perspective:

This is why we are advocates of the student/athlete model.  Go to school for 4 years, become part of the campus culture, enjoy the college experience, and earn your degree.  Even if you don't make the pros you have something to fall back on.  Nerlens Noel was projected to be a top 5 pick.  What about now?  Will he ever be the same player?  If he's been taking his education seriously he's created an insurance policy for himself.

When it's all said and done I hope this kid comes back good as new and gets the chance to continue pursuing his dream of becoming an NBA player.  His injury serves as a stark reminder that life comes at you fast and your path to success is not always linear.  There are bumps in the road and obstacles to navigate and overcome.  Good luck Nerlens Noel.

Tuesday, February 12, 2013

Is Dan Marino Still A Hero?

I can't believe he did that to his wife.  I used to have a lot of respect for that guy, but now I think he's an a$$hole.  His wife should divorce him and take him for everything he's worth!

Dayna Wilson

A few weeks ago reports surfaced that Hall of Fame quarterback Dan Marino fathered a love child out of wedlock and paid the mother millions of dollars to keep quiet about it.  It was an embarrassing admission for the Marino family and tarnished what was otherwise considered a squeaky clean image.  Infidelity in itself isn't a crime, but did Dan Marino lose the case in the court of popular opinion?

Let me start out by saying I'm completely biased when it comes to the subject of Dan Marino.  He is one of my favorite athletes of all time (not just football) and I have way too many positive memories about Dan to be objective.  I've won thousands of dollars betting on Dolphins games, seen miraculous comebacks, and touchdown passes that defied the laws of physics.  Dan is a legend on the football field and his personal indiscretions (at present) don't offend me that much.

On the other hand I realize heroes and role models are held to a higher standard than most other individuals and the same rules don't apply.  People have a different level of expectation and their moral compass is meticulously scrutinized.  I don't condone what Dan Marino did, but I don't feel it's my place to judge another man's issues and the decisions he makes in life.  Everyone has things they may not want the whole world to know about them.

The bottom line is heroes and role models are human.  They are flawed and very few can live up to the persona and expectation other people put on them.  If you look at it from that perspective you won't be disappointed or upset to find out they're not perfect.  It would be wrong to forget or discount all of his great deeds because of one bad mistake.  Dan Marino is still a hero in my eyes.  Your thoughts?